@MichaelHortonRocks
I have that Osprey. I’ve used it for about 5 years. You said it “looks” flimsy, well I can tell you from experience it actually isn’t flimsy, it’s quite durable. And the compression flaps can cinch it down tight no matter the size of the load. Sure it looks like a backpack, but it feels great while traveling. And the one compartment situation can be solved by fabric cubes. Totally worth the price.
@Charlotte-rr5dh
I have that osprey pack, but I have the version that has a smaller pack that can either attach to the pack itself or you can wear in the front and I love it. yes it doesn’t have a ton of different pockets inside but a couple packing cubes is really all you need and the hip belts are a game changer when carrying a heavy pack through multiple airports as well as the ability to zip up the straps and make it a pure duffel bag if you need to check it without having anything ripped off
@sara781
Well, you sold me the Aer... This was a tremendously helpful video. I always overthink purchases and spend excessive time researching the options, so I am really grateful for all of your work on this!
@manfella
By no means a Cotopaxi stan nor do I even use the Allpa, but why would you buy a bag that's too big and then rank it out because it's too big? They have a 35L bag that should have been compared here
@klingrw1
Great video! Could you do another video for personal item backpacks to use as a supplement to carry on roller luggage?
@lisawoodward432
This was super helpful. I'd also like to see your spreadsheet, so I could know the data not mentioned for certain bags - for example, how size compliant, how much they weigh, etc. Thanks Nik!
@JonathanPichot
This is how you do a comparison video! Straight to the point, nuanced comparisons to help folks with different requirements. Thanks for the great info.
@elqord.1118
As a business traveler 7:34 made me snort and laugh. I‘m trying to imagine in what world I could walk around with a fridge like that on my back
@ge48421
I like the Tomtoc, it's light (under 3 pounds/1.5 kg), which was extremely useful flying with New Zealand Air that has a carry-on weight limit of 7kg, and they did check and tagged my bag as "approved". 6.9kg, phew! Positives: - weight, you can carry 5.5 kilograms of useful stuff even on a restrictive carrier. - front pocket is useful to carry travel documents (proof you have a return ticket and travel authorization, address of your first hotel etc.) - the pocket on top is large enough to cram your wallet and phone in before you go through security. - It does not have a lot of organization features, I use my own pouches/cubes anyway. Negatives: - the fabric is of reasonable but not top quality (and consequently weighs less) - you usually have the ends of straps flopping around because there's nothing keeping them in check. Conclusion: not perfect, but I'd buy it again.
@bytejump
I was really interested in the conclusions and I was only confused by how you talked about the Aer. You mentioned the great clamshell opening, perfect for organizing with packing cubes, the great top pocket for sunglasses, etc. - all of which were things you stated as negatives for the Osprey. It was bizarre. And I think you missed one of the best elements of the Osprey - that it is absurdly comfortable to wear packed.
@festej
3:42 Literally laughed out loud with your "Hey man, where's the hostel?" critique. I totally understand and agree.
@VideoProVideo
Great video. I have Peak design 45L for a three years. I really tested this backpack as a travel bag. I took it with me in Canada, USA, Great Britain, France, Czech Republic, Italy, Switzerland. It is enough to draw conclusions BENEFITS: - strong - holds a lot - good material - really very good for the camera negative: - it is very heavy even empty - there is no net on the internal wall , which makes you sweat uncontrollably in the summer - inside, in particular, the cubes/sections are not cheap either, which makes it even more expensive that's why I use it exclusively as a gear backpack. And for travel, I found a very good replacement OSPREY parsec and very happy with that choice
@rand-san2095
Can you do a video about "personal item" size bags? I usually do a 1 carry-on roller + 1 underseat backpack combo.
@thomasfoldes
Great video. You’re never going to know what works best for you until you pack it up and use it. My advice, for long-term travel (more than a week)- if you have something already use it and see what you like and don’t. What seems like the best option will probably change as you travel. We started with Tumi roller backpacks and ended up giving them away for the Osprey 40L w/ the matching 15L setup. But that’s what’s worked for us. Do we look like we’re heading to a hostile in our 50’s sure- do we care- nope. Great video to get people started, but never be afraid to change it up.
@RyanKry
Good video mate. Just an fyi for anyone's interested in the bag: The Peak Design 45l travel bag is 30 liters in its smallest setting (non-expanded and the top is buckled up), 35 liters (+5l) at default, and 45 liters (+10l) at its fully expanded format. Most of the time it will end up remaining as a 35-liter backpack like the AER 35l, it is great for carry-on with all airlines. When it is expanded to 45 liters, it is not carry-on compatible any longer with almost any airline. At its 30-liter form, it is still way too big to be considered as a daily, though. I'm quite happy with the bag, I'd only consider an Ultra fabric version of Aer 35 or maybe Tortuga light if I were to switch things up out of boredom.
@pbneeks
I watch a lot of bag reivew channels on YouTube and I gotta say there is something unique about your channel that separates it from the others! I think its how you get straight to the point point out the pros and cons and give a logical and thought out explanation on which bag to go with! Great video keep up the awesome work! 😎
@john1023va
I love my Aer travel pack 3. It is hands down the best for what it does. I have been scouring YouTube for years and haven't find anything comparable to it. This bag should last me for decades of moderate traveling.
@JB-eg1tb
I was very close to getting AER. One thing that led me to go with PAKT is the depth of the water bottle holder as that was something I've learned to value. Other bags I've had caused the water bottle to fall. I appreciate the work and resources to make this video! And yes, I chose your PAKT link when I purchased mine about a month ago.
@onewhoisanonymous
I have the Osprey 46 and it is the best for my travels. Yes, I do look like a backpacker with it, but has been a great bag. What sold me with the Osprey over the Tomtoc is the ability to compress down the pack really well with its side flaps. This backpack has saved me on a few trips where size of the bag was important on flights. BUT the issue is the Osprey is a little too big. I really appreciate this video and I am always on the lookout for a new backpack.
@awaytogether