@nighthawk6281
Basically an architects dream is a civil engineers nightmare
@ronaldmontalbo8592
Let's also keep in mind that the construction workers had took a great part in the project. Because without them their plans would not be possible.
@vidyatayade1210
Let's not judge such things as how people are doing in comments... Both work deserves respect😊
@rennycepeda6576
architects don't just put "aesthetics" they DESIGN. Man people who arent into the field have no idea how much thinking is put in every single space we make. When i design i have to think about the plumbing, electricity, the structure, how the space will feel, the climate, the materials, and a lot more. Only mediocre architects go around throwing stuff without thinking in all the other fields that need to work together
@sajidahnaf
The comment section really shows how unaware people are about the construction industry. Nonetheless, the video was very accurate. When designing a building, making it structurally sound is just as important as making sure it functions properly. A project can completely fail if either engineers or architects fail to do their jobs properly. At the end of the day, even though both architects and civil engineers have to adhere to strict rules and regulations, every project is different and requires innovative problem-solving.
@aneeshas335
Architecture and civil engineering are like both sides of a coin, both depends on each other, so instead of blaming do respect, that's what wise people do.
@adriangutz
I'm glad my architecture course in my uni is really diverse so I actually know a lot of construction and structural knowledge, I just got taught metallic structures (a los of physics) last semester and it's amazing, I make make structurally sound bridges now which is cool.
@ramontanglao6466
There is no conflict between the two. 50 years as an architect I never got a problem with engineers.
@vilecypher
Wait what. No. The architects not only focus on looks and aesthetics. They make sure all clearances for engineering aspects work in 3d space (mechanical, structural, plumbing/sanitary, etc.). Structural isn't only the technical part. The architects manages all these technical parts to make it work. Together with all these technical aspects, the architect is the only one who considers aesthetics.
@billcorr4913
There are many civil engineering structures that have no or minimal input from architects- hydraulic channel and chambers, Treatment works. drainage, cable support, etc towers,
@breemudi
But this is assuming that the only department in civil engineering is 'structural design'... We also have soil mechanics, Water resources, geotechnics and much more
@ikanputih
When the building succesfull : people's says, who's the architect ? When the building collapse :people's says who's the civil engineer ?
@DWisesman180
The comments section was boom😅😅😅😅 Architects vs Civil engineering...as an aspiring architect, I believe both deserve credit coz they simply complements each others work.👍👍👍👍
@abhijeetpradhan5202
A structurally strong building with unmanaged function and space is still a failure as a building. Civil and architects work do overlap but their work and practice are completely different things. Stereotypes are cringing me out in this comment section.
@minhngoctran7271
I think ill learn the engineering path after finishing my architecture degree, seems interesting
@leafgreen_g
I think people who try to compete here which one deserves more are forgetting that civil engineering derived from architecture back in the 1950 architects were the architectural engineers they did both. So lets appreciate both.
@anokarop4650
ALLOW me to tell whosoever that is trying to join architectural engineering department that it is hard, tiresome but fun.... if you love and are interested in it, you’ll persevere through it and succeed.. it only takes commitment ❤️💯 it’s such a beautiful career tho
@Roymambomigosi
Pursuing Degree of Bachelor of Science in Civil and Structural Engineering, and for sure the success of any high-rise building, bridge, airport, stadium, tarmac road, railway,dam and terminus to mention but a few, fully depends on structural soundness. Therefore, an Engineer holds promise to success of these structures! 💯
@akitodaisuke6532
Even if engineers and architecture use their educational resource but those are labours from whom our world has developed. Respect to every labours from around the world 🌎
@Mackyanguson